‘A Different Image’ Breaks Down The Stigmatized Roles Ingrained In Our Mindsets

 

A Different Image promo image.

Alile Sharon Larkin’s A Different Image addresses the theory that some men will set women up to believe in a false friendship— a scheme that has existed since the dawning of time. They disguise their true intentions in order to become closer to another goal altogether.

That’s the unfortunate case between Alana and Vincent. 

Alana (Margòt Saxton-Federella) at rest. DP: Charles Burnett.
  

Alana draws a neighborhood boy (who later shockingly disrespects her). DP: Charles Burnett.

The stylish Alana, a talented visual artist and office receptionist, lives faraway from her family, enjoying her secluded, mix-patterned space decorated in vintage photographs of Black people and an eclectic array of objects relating to African diaspora. Her independent vibe is carefree and spiritual, the wonderful traits creatives usually exhibit. 

Alana also enjoys a camaraderie with Vincent, a young man in her class. They eat lunch together, do yoga, and read books— platonic activities. Diane, a nosy co-worker, believes that Alana and Vincent are bound to become an item soon. When dismissing the notion, no guile is in Alana’s response. No mischievous eyes or blushing smile that suggests anything more than stern disinterest. Alana buys into her friendship with Vincent one hundred percent because that is all that she hopes to obtain from him. She even requests that he give her an African name, instilling trust in such a meaningful task. 

Yet, this brings up the paradoxical question— can men and women be just that? 

What if the other falls in love and wants more? 

Vincent (Adisa Anderson) scopes out a woman (Bella Dilworth). DP: Charles Burnett. 

Ralph (Michael Bruce) encourages Vincent to act on his desires. DP: Charles Burnett.

Vincent is already seduced by societal’s masculine expectations. He often stares at the billboards and adult magazines featuring fit, beautiful women, a natural part of patriarchal conditioning that has men viewing women’s bodies as lust objects. A crude young boy who objectifies Alana while she’s drawing him signifies how early this misconduct starts. 

Although Vincent seems to want to stay on the right track, he is bitten hard by societal expectations, drawn not to seeing women beyond sexual relief. It’s displayed in how he looks at them once they past him by, his body language is suspect. Plus, his hands begin lingering too long on Alana, computing how much she lets him get away with. 

It also doesn’t help that testosterone heavy friend Ralph eggs Vincent to “do something” with Alana. Ralph— the scandalous devil on Vincent’s shoulder— believes Alana is leading Vincent on, that her friendship is only a facade that must be preyed on. Ralph presents a problematic advisor, pushing the agenda even further, conflicting Vincent’s already troubling mindset.  

Ralph is too busy with Alicia (Mandisa Oliver) to help Vincent move— again a demonstration of his deplorable character. DP: Charles Burnett.

Alana crashes on Vincent’s floor. DP: Charles Burnett.

At the climax, Alana’s trusting nature becomes her downfall to Vincent’s compromised mental state. The fault is not hers. Alana did not cause Vincent’s predatory nature to unveil itself. He is a manifestation of both his environment and the constant voice in his head (Ralph) promoting destructive behavior, unleashing the need to assert dominance. When Alana realizes that she cannot be vulnerable around Vincent, that he does not comprehend a women’s multifaceted personhood, let alone their emotional integrity and consent, the perceived friendship is tainted and unsafe. Vincent does give Alana an African name, but the bond between them has been severed, especially since he doesn’t offer a genuine explanation for his violation. She can forgive him. 

Yet, forgetting what he did…

Furthermore, Alana lives alone in an unfamiliar place, isolated with little friends. If anything, it’s easier to believe that she will eventually cut ties with Vincent. She may find another who respects her boundaries or searches for positive girlfriends. At least she has art to express her innermost emotions in the meantime— the best form of therapy and happiness. 

A conflicted Vincent tries to play cards. Does he understand that what did to Alana was wrong? Is that what guilt looks like? DP: Charles Burnett.

A guarded Alana in deep thought, perhaps unsettled by both the burden of her own naivety and trying to move past Vincent’s corrupt behavior. DP: Charles Burnett. 

Images are the first things we understand before words and definitions. Beneath certain pronounced cues delivering outdated gender norms, subliminal messages can have lasting effects as demonstrated in Vincent’s character. 

A Different Image harbors between short film and feature-length, containing the moralistic edge apparent in most L. A. Rebellion works. A few renowned members provided aid to writer, producer, and director Alile Sharon Larkin— Charles Burnett as cinematographer and Julie Dash on continuity. The actors played their roles well— Margòt Saxton-Federella in her only part and Adisa Anderson (Daughters of the Dust) present a conflict that still exists today. It’s a familiar story about society’s mental interference, women’s roles in a limited man’s imagination, and that women must still have to be careful about “wolves in sheep’s clothing.”